noodler's ink controversy

It simply lays down a solid, bright, blue line. From an early age, Nathan was obsessed with fountain pens and believed that they were superior to any other writing instrument. Noodler's 54th Massachusetts - 3oz Bottled Ink. In response, Nathan Tardiff, the wizard behind the Noodlers curtain, posted a video defending the behavior of Baystate Blue. I love this brand! From what I can discern, only the ink that gets absorbed by the paper can be considered water-fast. Second, it can and will actively stain the plastic parts of a pen, though a solution of bleach and water will apparently remove most of the color from plastic; it is not an easy ink to clean out of a pen. Noodler's Ink. Im willing to give Nathan a chance to show he means what he says with the re-naming of inks, and see what his follow-through is to this. Polar inks are useful down to -114 degrees F (-81 degrees C). Allowing people to atone for what theyve done (not just forgiving them outright, but letting them put in the work) is a Jewish value, after all. Rubber Stamps also offer an economical option other than the self-inking and pre-inked stamps. If youve spent much time in the fountain pen hobby, and youve done even a little research on blue inks, youve likely run on to the controversy surrounding Noodlers Baystate Blue. Silicone Casting Material, Casting Silicone, Casting Kits, Casting Frames, Dental Casting Materials, Tire and Footprint Casting. Review materials: For the wide strokes, I used three calligraphy pens: Pilot Parallel 6.0mm and 3.8mm pens, and a 1.9 mm Lamy Joy. Smoother, premium papers like Rhodia arent as absorbent, so more of the ink dries on top of the paper instead of absorbing into the fibers. Ammonia usually does the trick. Change). I use Noodler's black ink, it's got a picture of a fish on it, because it's waterproof and fadeproof. Its very symbolic, relevant, and a totally unique way of branding an ink color. Some plastics and metals will react poorly to bleach. Its highly pigmented and consistently produces high-quality ink at an affordable price. Industrial Aerospace Inks, Epoxy Inks, Solvents/Thinners, Inspection Stamps. That particular set of Lamy feed was made of a similar cheap plastic. But, thanks in large part to this sub, and to the robust conversations and personal experiences so many of you have shared over the last two days, things are changing. I like the ink. On Rhodia in a medium nib it dried in 4 seconds. As you can tell from the above, BSB is one of the most high maintenance inks on the market. Maybe I'm expecting too much from a small business since I didn't frequent his site before today so I don't know what might have changed recently. The idea of having an ink that stands up to water appeals to me, but it has been a bit of a learning curve for myself. They are functional and stable, but not an objet dart intended for the top of ones desk. Noodlers Borealis Black 3oz Ink Bottle - Starting at $12.50. Anyway, thank you clearing up a few cobwebs. Borealis Black ink was inspired by the decadent black ink colors of the 1950s. In 2017, Noodlers released a new color called A House Divided. Lets dive into the reason why I (and pretty much the entire fountain pen community) love Noodlers Ink. Its not necessarily the inks fault. What is good pen hygiene? ETA: Ive never used bleach on a pen and never plan to. Thank you for this explanation. The brand itself has its detractors, yet I cant understand why. On the copier paper, it creates a light blue tint in the affected area. So I thought maybe I was the only huge Noodlers fan until I read this. That said, Baystate Blue has earned equal shares of fame and infamy among the fountain pen community. Several years ago Noodlers began to introduce inks that were variable combination such as Navy, Green Marine, Blue-Black, Aircorp, Zhivago, Kiowa Pecan, Walnut, Brown, Red-Black, Golden Brown, #41 Brown, etc The first variable combination formulas were manufactured with variables being different on a PER BOTTLE basismeaning EVERY bottle has slightly different ink component proportions. Only 4 left in stock - order soon. Noodler's Ink Konrad Flex Nib Clear Demo Piston Fill Fountain Pen. Baystate Blue performed best on the absorbent paper of an Ecosystem author journal, which is unsurprising given the other Noodlers inks Ive tested. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); You MUST use good FP Hygiene. If you do have staining, BSB can be cleaned up with ammonia OR bleach (never together or you could kill yourself! Baystate inks are slightly more alkaline than most inks (the bottle lists that pH as somewhere between 8 and 9). Plastic, skin, porcelainpretty much anything it touches apart from glass will be left a few shades bluer than it started. What happens when water sits in an open air container? ), Nathan Tardiff, the founder of Noodlers, wrote a letter that explained the origin of the name. (Read the full letter here.). He'd apparently been informed very thoroughly the first time he did the antisemitic label, this isn't "I'm sorry, I didn't know" this is "Oh shit I might lose my income.". There may also be some ingredients in the ink that react poorly to SOME plastics. It really is that simple so far as Im concerned. Named for Boris Pasternaks classic novel. You may not always be amazed, but you will never be disappointed. Its extremely saturated. Inspired by vintage cobalt-based inks, Baystate Blue is one of the most vibrant, high-contrast fountain pen inks on the market. Time/Date/Numbering Machines, Automatic Check signing Machines. Noodlers Polar inks are specially formulated to resist freezing in temperatures down to -20F. Actually, I'm quite sad to see the tribe names go. However, they feather quite badly, so we dont recommend them unless you need their anti-freezing properties. Ive had zero problems with Noodlers Ink. My eyes couldnt skip them if they tried. There was no bleeding on Tomoe River. Whats not to like? But we decided to let yesterdays post (and the offshoot posts) stay up, so long as everyone was trying to follow the rules. This ink is marketed as being waterproof, and here, once again, my results varied depending on the paper. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Its a light reddish colorquite pretty, but which some would say may resemble the look of dried blood. Inspection Stamps, Non-Porous Super Stamps, Lipstick Inspection Stamps, Invisible Stamps. I had a hard time getting large swabs of this ink to dry. If 2+ incompatible inks are mixed the mixture will produce sediments, precipitants, sludge, slim, and various other nasty things that will lead to clogged pens! On the other hand, filling an already wet-writing pen with eel ink can cause problems with excessive ink flow. This also happens with fountain pen inks. Use household bleach to clean up BSB stains, but be careful with using bleach on your pens as some plastics do not interact well with it. The fountain pen community has the same issues as every other hobby community does. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. I've never seen an ink do that before. ), John, Knowing I Am, Holy Spirit, Kevin P. Larson, Karas Kustoms Fountain K Fountain Pen Review. Commonwealth 2021 (with closed captions from a fish) Liberty's only darkness is the line upon the paper. We are your industry leader for marking products, including Rubber Stamps, Self-Inking Stamps, Pre-Inked stamps, Inspection Stamps, Steel Stamps, Fingerprint Pads, Industrial Inks and so much more.Our marking devices help you put your name, company brand or fingerprint everywhere it needs to be!. For the better. rubyophidian. The thing is, he IS a very knowing and politically engaged asshole who gladly dog whistled his adoring fans, there is no way on this earth that he didn't know EXACTLY what he was doing, there is no way he didn't mean it absolutely as it comes across, and there is no way that he is genuinely sorry. And from the first bottle of Noodlers Black, Nathan has been pushing the envelope of what fountain pen ink can do. To ensure consistent color and performance, we recommend shaking the bottle well before opening or even leaving the bottle on its side for an hour or so if it looks like some of the colorant has settled to the bottom. Thank goodness for samples! If it was something Tardif had written himself, why include that? IDK if I 100% agree with that analysis, but its interesting. Im fortunate enough not to have had any accidents yet with BSB, but apparently clothes, carpet, and countertops are instant garbage if they come in contact with the ink. Im not saying that the other brands arent great, or that all of Noodlers inks are best-in-class. I guess I'll have to find another fadeproof, waterproof black ink (not that I use a lot these days, one bottle has lasted me nearly five years at this point, but still I'm now ashamed to own that one single bottle). There was (and has been, historically) some discussion amongst the mods about letting posts critical of Noodlers stay up and active because of how out of control the comments sections can become. Latent Print Powders, Latent Print Powder Applicators & Remover, Print Lifters - Hinged Print Lifters - Tape & Backing Cards, Latent Print Developers and Supplies. I'm 3rd gen Cauhuilla and I loved seeing the little references to the beautiful parts of a culture that's all but erased now. As a matter of fact its my favorite ink, and I use it in all of my pens regardless of the cost of the pen. My impression of Nathan has always been of a decent person whose beef with Bernanke has always been economics. Rather, it is an electric cobalt blue that positively jumps off the page. I can make it a dedicated BSB pen, or simply always pair it with a blue ink. Clear demonstrators will usually end up with a permanent Baystate Blue tint. As far as I know, Noodler's inks aren't really any different from how they've always been, but like all brands, the behavior is an attribute of the individual ink, not the line. If you choose to use Ammonia, a diluted solution of 10 parts water to 1 part ammonia is generally safe for fountain pens (save casein or milk celluloid which can dissolve in water). Bleach, for example destroys most so-called organic security components in a matter of seconds and is a frequent tool of the forger though it is often also useful for identification of underlying properties (as with the ink called Prime of the Commons). This is the best black ink in the world, she gushed. Honestly I'm relieved how this turned out. Ive never had that experience with Noodlers inks. It is up to you to decide whether or not you will use BSB. Since then people have reported using BSB in Lamy pens without problems. An interesting comment from the original thread that I think bears repeating: The quotation mark at the end of this statement implies that it was copy pasted from a prepared statement. Each bottle includes a Charlie rollerball pen, which can be filled with the bottles eyedropper. One of the things I really love about Noodlers is that it puts a lot of thought both into the quality of the ink, and even the name of the ink**. That 3% is largely dyes, and overly concentrated dyes will clog pens! But under black light, the ink actually looks blue. It can feather and bleed through on some papers while behaving fine on other, seemingly identical papers. Yep, this was my biggest thought too. The ink drops also bled, showing the underlying blue. Third, Noodlers indicates that Baystate Blue should not be mixed with other inks except for those in the Baystate line, as the pH value is more alkaline than other inks in the Noodlers line. Volker Green happened before Bernanke Red and there was a huge reaction then too, right? "Noodling" is a technique for catching catfish by hand. Additionally, some of the colorants can settle at the bottom of the bottle, and it can take more than a quick shake to mix them back into the ink. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Because fountain pens should be for everyone and every situation, Nathan is also committed to having the lowest price per volume of any ink on the market. I wouldnt count on BSB if youre working in an office and are commonly scribbling on copy paper. See the FAQ for an explanation. Ok thank you. I hope he, and many others, have learned something from this. The soak test, in which I run the paper under a stream of water, resulted in a blurry blue mess on the Rhodia paper, though, to be fair, the lines are all still discernable. 4.1 4.1 out of 5 stars (136) $24.80 $ 24. Dry time was about 10 to 12 seconds. You can find me @mountainofink on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest. However, BSB is one of nearly 100 inks offered by Noodlers. Thoughts on Tactile Turns Trailhead (Seasonal Release). More Buying Choices $24.40 (5 new offers) Noodlers Ink 3 Oz Nightshade. This claim emerged with the report of a series of melted Lamy feeds. Then, when the sun comes and the ink thaws, youre left with an ink spill of nightmare proportions. For example, I love using the Vintage Style inks when I write in my bullet journal because the color matches the vintage stickers that I use. All Polar inks are also Bulletproof. For the fine strokes, I used a Lamy EF steel nib on a Lamy Safari. I had this issue with all of the pens I tried the ink in. YMMV, Some report success using BSB in Mont Blanc piston fillers. Noodler's House Divided was created for the 2017 DC Pen Show. What follows is a mixture of my experiences with Noodlers and a brief analysis of the Noodlers debate. Noodlers Polar Inks also have the same lubricating properties as American Eel Inks. I laid out EVERYTHINGGG that I needed for the wedding and Ghia, the designer/writer, in my email before I met . We hope weve inspired you to give Noodlers Inks a try. , I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. These inks resist UV light, UV light wands, bleaches . Art stamps, creative inks and a huge assortment of art stamping supplies. Because the permanence of bulletproof ink comes from its special ability to bind with the cellulose fibers in paper, it works best on ordinary, lightly textured paper such as standard copy paper. It was a bummer to see the labels in question, and when their broader context was defined the labels were indefensible. I like the ink. One of the reasons I love fountain pens is that I love very vivid and rich colors. Is Noodlers Ink good? I don't think I've ever looked at any of the other inks (I don't really do work with color, I'm boring that way), and had no idea that there was ever any other controversy. Other inks in this category are Private Reserve inks, iron gall inks, and some Diamine inks. Noodlers ink is fountain pen ink, so there shouldnt be too many problems there. I think Bernake Red came first but Volkner green had the backlash first (probably because it was a lot easier to see the antisemitism without having to actually look at the bottle art) but he's had backlash over a lot of other things so you'd think he'd be more careful. I used both the coated paper of a Rhodia Dot Pad and the absorbent paper taken from my home office laser printer. Noodlers has fewer colors than other brands, but it does have a lot of different kinds of ink formulas. Im happy to hear that you are addressing this. Some people really love it. All (M)SDS Sheets are available for your documentations. The paper is Rhodia 80g. Then along came the new Noodler's Berning Red ($12.50), and my decision became a little easier. "Eternal" refers to any Noodler's Ink that resists the effects of time - moisture, humidity, UV light, acids, water exposure, and many common detergents such as dish soaps and household ammonia, as well as alcohols and acetone (which conventional ball point pens have no resistance to - often rinsing off a newly written check within 8 seconds of It's is not the brand's job . Custom Rubber Stamps come in several shapes, sizes and models of stamps. Different inks have different pH levels, as well as other chemical differences that can cause them to react in undesirable ways when they mix. I mean it was pretty clear he was a libertarian lunatic when I first went to his website eight years ago, and I'm not the slightest bit surprised to hear that he's only gotten more radicalized. Noodler's House Divided was created for the 2017 DC Pen Show. FAA Airport Runway Stencils, Choose from 3 feet to 12 feet. Another interesting thing. My favorite brown ink is Diamine Saddle Brown, Diamine Chocolat, and Mont Blanc Toffee Brown. Lots of colors are available. Noodler's Ink is one of the lowest cost per volume on the market. Details Bleeding: Medium-there was a fair amount of bleeding on Baron Fig and Rhodia, and just a little bit on Leuchtturm. 15w. Ignore the generic ink brands with iffy quality. Celluloid is one oft cited victim. Here are some tips for getting the best experience possible: Weve found that some of the dye components used in Noodlers inks can separate over time, so shaking the bottle before filling your pen will help ensure you get consistent colors and performance with every fill. I think this is a positive move. By definition, the coated Rhodia paper absorbs far less ink than the printer paper, and consequently shows much worse behavior. Ink swabs for comparison, left to right (top to bottom for RSS): Faber-Castell Garnet Red, Noodler's House Divided, and Organics Studio Mercury Red. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Its a polarizing conversation. I thought something was wrong with my eyes! We also discuss our own projects and musings in weekly WIP threads. As for its blues and blanks, you can count on a bright color that stays bright, unlike other fountain pen inks that fade after a few months. Since 36 is 18 x 2 it's like one for each. One of Noodler's most popular inks is their Baystate Blue, a part of their Baystate series, which also includes Cape Cod Cranberry and Grape.. Each of the Baystate series is known for its bright, vibrant colors . It's a polarizing conversation. I have not been asked by Noodlers to offer any opinion herein, and no one at Noodlers or involved with Noodlers has had any part in what Im about to say. As an X-Feather ink, however, X-Feather Black takes a long time to dryespecially on less absorbent papers that are well suited to ordinary fountain pen inks. On smoother papers like Rhodia, however, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and prone to smudging. YMMV, Be careful using BSB in some cheap Chinese pens (some are made of a plastic that BSB can melt), To shake or not to shake? I hope you can all forgive me (and buy my stuff, please, pandering to right wing lunatics doesn't pay nearly as well as I expected. Noodlers responded by changing the names of many of their inks. )", I can't take his apology seriously. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. I find it easy to pick out on the page, certainly, but I think pages upon pages of it would drive me nuts. The maker of Noodler's Ink, Nathan Tardif, has acknowledged that there are certain "cheap Asian" plastics with which Baystate Blue (BSB) does not play nice. - YouTube 0:00 / 6:08 Noodler's Ink vs. Goulet Pens. Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. Part of Noodlers, Its surprisingly hard to find a true red ink, but we think. So if you get a bottle of ink, divide the total number of milliliters by the total price, Noodlers will generally be cheaper than other brands. It also has a wide range of inks, from fast-drying to fluorescent, and even archival inks that will never fade. You guys are truly amazing. To me it looks like a red-brown. There was a very low level of feathering, only moderate show-through, and no bleed-through that I could discern. Later on additional variables were perfected that included: specific fluorescent identifier components (you can tell if your ink has these by testing with a black light, Luxury Blue is an example), specific chemical identifier components (such as those that fade before certain test chemicals leaving the rest of the ink an observably different color), specific UV and IR reactive/resistant components (laser resistance and age maturation upon the page, the Wardens ink series for example), and most recently components specific in their behavior to certain fountain pen nibs (soon to be introduced), and a combination lock of inks currently available in very small quantities in Australia, Germany, and Japan (hand made and complex quantities of such inks are limited and may be introduced more broadly at a later date). I'm just sad it took this long. How do I know if they areaccurate? Baystate Blue has generated a bit of controversy lately. Noodlers themselves warn against using any of the Baystate line of inks if you are uncomfortable with the possibility of permanently altering the color scheme of your kitchen. Prehensile Prints 190 subscribers Subscribe 269 8K views 6 months ago I give my take on the. In the video, he demonstrates no feathering or bleed-through on cheap copier paper. In the mid-1940s, a popular ink was created in Boston that replicated the vibrant blue of colonial-era cobalt-based inks. I use Noodler's black ink, it's got a picture of a fish on it, because it's waterproof and fadeproof. Even still, one must be careful not to over generalize. In that case, you will have the same issue with any of the saturated inks because they have a lower water content (ie it takes less time for the water in the ink to evaporate when exposed to air) than some of the more watery inks like Lamy. With so many lines and colors to choose from, theres sure to be one thats perfect for you. The Man Behind Noodler's Ink - Q&A Slices - YouTube What makes Noodler's Ink so unique? Its significantly more intense than Pilots Asa-gao. You wont lose your work if you drop your notebook into the ocean and then jump in to recover it. The heavy duty bottom frame is made entirely of metal. Extra Large 48" - 72" - 96" Stencil Sets & Kits, Sand Blast Rubber Stencil Material and Custom Cut Stencils, School Students Drop-Off and Pick-Up Street Stencils. (This website uses referral links. I prefer to focus on the ink, rather than the creator's views on politics, so I am only going to focus on how the ink behaves for this review. Our marking devices help you put your name, company brand or fingerprint everywhere it needs to be! Noodlers inks come in a standard 3 oz. The number 18 is represented by the letters het (8) + yud (10). May 11, 2022 Which brings us to this week's revelation. On the other end of the feathering spectrum, If you want a conventional black ink without the mixed pros and cons of bulletproof inks, go for, If your pen or converter has a sticky piston, filling it up with a lubricating dose of.

Tylenol Murders Theories, Ssm Health Scrubs And Beyond, Fresh Start Head Start Inventory, All Inclusive Elopement Packages Mn, Articles N

noodler's ink controversy